剧情介绍
法国1992年皮埃尔.斯科恩多弗编导的经典战争名作,影片从一个美国战地记者的眼光看着名的奠边府之役,颇给人启发。强权被弱者打败,传为千古被誉为“军事上的奇迹”。奠边府位于越南北部紧靠上寮,1954年初,在奠边府集结的法军共有2万多人,除步兵和伞兵之外,还...展开全部 法国1992年皮埃尔.斯科恩多弗编导的经典战争名作,影片从一个美国战地记者的眼光看着名的奠边府之役,颇给人启发。强权被弱者打败,传为千古被誉为“军事上的奇迹”。奠边府位于越南北部紧靠上寮,1954年初,在奠边府集结的法军共有2万多人,除步兵和伞兵之外,还...收起全部 It is unbelievable how incompetent this film director is! Pierre Schoendoerffer certainly doesn't know his business, AT ALL!Everything is inept: the camera doesn't know where to go (say, meaninglessly aiming at a puddle of water in the wirport; or, again, meaninglessly shooting against lumination, from the back of a platoon of soldiers......), the soundtrack never wakes up from the director's reverie of his school-yard drill, and the "actors"---if they can be called that! The plot is non-existent: the director apparently believes that, since Dien Bien Phu was such a catastrophy for the Gauls, no plot would have made the audience feel anything like a purpose anyway; so why bother?!Some say that this movie talks too much. Let me assure you you will be very misled to think it is some stereotypically clever French dialogue that cheats you out of more gutteral pleasure ---no Sir! You will be totally safe from the fell contamination of any intellect from those drab, obvious, stupid conversations!For those who wish to get a shot of adrenalin from this movie: DON'T. If you are really desperate, you will be better off bringing a tape recorder to anywhere in downtown Shanghai, next Chinese New Year: when the happy Shanghai-nese start to set off the fire-crackers, the sound effect will be so much closer to battlegorund experience than anything this kindergarten movie has ever accomplished!And will save you 8RMB, too.